Paid advertising has shifted dramatically in recent years. Once, retargeting—following users with ads after they had visited your site—was one of the most powerful tools in a marketer’s arsenal. Retargeting made it easy to show ads to people who were already interested in your product or service, giving you a second chance to convert those users.

However, new privacy rules and regulations have made it harder to track users and serve retargeted ads. Devices, browsers, and even new legislation are rejecting cookies and tracking codes, forcing businesses to rethink how they approach paid ads.

In this article, we’ll explore the challenges posed by these new privacy rules and how you can pivot your paid ad strategy without relying on retargeting.

The Impact of New Privacy Rules on Retargeting

Over the last few years, global privacy regulations and changes to browser policies have made it more difficult for advertisers to track users across the web. This shift is largely driven by growing concerns over data privacy. In response, many major players in the tech space have implemented measures to protect users’ data.

1. Third-Party Cookie Bans: One of the biggest challenges is the rejection of third-party cookies, which were essential for retargeting.

Google Chrome, which accounts for over 60% of browser traffic, is set to phase out third-party cookies by the end of 2024. Safari and Firefox have already done so.

Third-party cookies were the primary method for tracking user behavior across multiple websites, allowing advertisers to retarget users with personalized ads.

2. Device Tracking Restrictions: Apple’s iOS 14.5 update introduced App Tracking Transparency (ATT), a feature that requires users to opt in before their activity can be tracked across apps and websites.

According to Flurry Analytics, over 80% of iPhone users have opted out of tracking, severely limiting advertisers’ ability to retarget these users.

3. Regulatory Changes: Global regulations such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in Europe and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) in the U.S. have increased the focus on data privacy. These laws give consumers more control over their personal data, making it harder for businesses to collect and use tracking data without explicit consent.

The Challenges of Advertising Without Retargeting

Without retargeting, advertisers face several new challenges:

• Loss of Audience Data: With cookies and tracking codes being rejected, businesses are losing access to valuable data about user behavior.
• Higher Customer Acquisition Costs: Retargeting was a cost-effective way to bring users back to your site, often at a lower cost per acquisition (CPA) than targeting new users. Without it, businesses may see their ad spending increase as they have to reach new audiences.
• Less Personalization: Retargeting allows for highly personalized ads based on a user’s previous interactions with your site. Without that data, ads may be less relevant to users, leading to lower conversion rates.

How to Pivot Your Paid Ad Strategy Without Retargeting

While these changes present significant challenges, they also offer an opportunity to rethink how you approach paid ads. Here are some strategies to pivot your advertising efforts and find success in this new landscape:

1. Focus on First-Party Data: With third-party cookies on the decline, first-party data has become more valuable than ever.

First-party data is information that you collect directly from your users, such as email addresses, phone numbers, and behavior on your own website.

Businesses should focus on building robust customer databases through email signups, loyalty programs, and CRM systems. By doing this, you can still reach customers without relying on third-party tracking.

2. Contextual Targeting: Contextual targeting is an effective alternative to retargeting. Instead of targeting users based on their past behavior, contextual targeting serves ads based on the content they are currently viewing. For example, if someone is reading a fitness article, you can show ads for workout gear. This strategy respects user privacy while still allowing for relevant advertising.

3. Leverage Lookalike Audiences: While retargeting relies on tracking individuals, lookalike audiences use algorithms to find new users who share characteristics with your existing customers. Platforms like Facebook and Google Ads allow you to upload your first-party data (e.g., email lists) to create lookalike audiences, helping you reach new potential customers who are similar to your current audience.

4. Invest in Search Ads: Search ads remain one of the most effective forms of advertising, as they target users who are actively searching for products or services like yours. Unlike display ads, search ads don’t rely on tracking user behavior. Instead, they match your ad to relevant search queries. By optimizing your keyword strategy, you can reach high-intent users without needing to retarget.

5. Create Engaging Content: If you can’t follow users around the web with ads, focus on drawing them back to your site with valuable, engaging content. Content marketing—whether through blogs, videos, or social media—can help you build brand awareness and attract organic traffic. Additionally, great content encourages users to stay longer on your site, increasing the chances of conversion without the need for retargeting.

According to a study by eMarketer, in 2021, 44% of marketers reported that data privacy changes had led to a drop in digital advertising effectiveness. However, companies that focused on first-party data and contextual targeting saw better results.

A recent case study from AdExchanger highlighted how an e-commerce company pivoted from retargeting to using lookalike audiences and first-party data. After losing a significant amount of tracking capabilities post-iOS 14.5, the company shifted its strategy, relying on customer email lists to build highly targeted lookalike audiences. This pivot not only helped recover their lost ROI but also improved their customer acquisition efforts by 15% within six months.

The shift toward greater data privacy presents challenges for advertisers who once relied on retargeting, but it also opens the door for more innovative strategies.

By focusing on first-party data, contextual targeting, lookalike audiences, and content marketing, you can pivot your paid ad strategy and continue driving growth without the need for retargeting. The key to success in this new era of advertising is adaptability and a willingness to embrace new methods of reaching and engaging your audience.

Ready to take your brand to the next level? Contact our experts today!